Skip to main content

Why Is God traditionally referred to with Male Pronouns?

A good response to the question "Is God male?", "Is God a woman?" in a classical philosophical viewpoint is this:


From the viewpoint of classical theism, or the traditional conception of God in a lot of Christian, Muslim, and Jewish thinkers (Aquinas, Maimonedes, and Avicenna to name a few),God is immutable, or unchangeable, immaterial, or incorporeal, eternal, or infinite, and purely actual. Considering this divine attributes, it would be very misleading to call God a "woman" or "she". Here's why.
An analogy from procreation would be helpful: In procreation, the role of the male is active insofar as he's the one impregnating. The role of the female, on the other hand, is passive insofar as she's the one being impregnated. After procreation, there is nothing in the male's physique that would apparently change due to procreation, only the woman will have changes in her physique (say, the stomach getting bigger).
Now, when we apply this analogy in understanding the relationship of God to the universe, God's role is active insofar as He's creating. The universe, on the other hand, has a passive role insofar as it's being created. And it would be important to note that Classical theism in general, and Aristotelian-Thomism in particular, emphasizes on what we call the "Doctrine of Divine Conservation", or the doctrine that says God's creation of the universe is ongoing, or that the universe is being preserved in existence here and now, as opposed to the fact that He only created the universe at one point in the past only (a good way of introducing this is diving deeper into Aquinas' 5 ways in proving God's existence. More on that next time probably). And also, since God is an unchangeable Being, His active role in creating the universe does not affect Him. Only the universe, which is being preserved in existence here and now, is changeable (This is self-evident from our experiences. The hot coffee becomes cold, our hair grows longer, etc.)
So, the point is: it would be very erroneous to refer to God with female pronouns, or calling Him 'mother', because we have Philosophical evidences that prove God's role and His relationship to the universe is a 'masculine role' while the universe is more of 'feminine' in relation to God.
Just as the woman cannot impregnate herself, The universe cannot create itself. The woman need someone from without to act in order for her to be impregnated, and the universe would need someone from without in order to be created.

- Matthew Luis Antero

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Wanna Make Things Right? Stop Prioritizing Justice

  Image by  Jill Wellington  from  Pixabay It seems to me that there is an intuitive sense within us fallen human beings to prioritize justice in a cold, blind sense before everything else. Yes, even before love or friendship, we aim to make sure that we are given our due and that people who have hurt us should be hurt as well, so that he or she can feel what we also felt. For instance, if we learn that a person we consider a friend is actually stabbing us in the back, the reasonable response seems to be to break the friendship apart and complain about this same friend to other people. This seems what is just in our eyes. And for us, as long as our sense of blind justice is preserved, all will be well. But for Christ, making things right does not mean prioritizing justice in the retributive sense of the word. Rather, for Him, justice is merely secondary to gratuitous, no-holds-barred Divine Mercy. Mercy always and everywhere is primary. Only when Mercy precedes justi...
Post a Comment
Read more

Squid Game and Catholic Social Teaching

  Note: This blogpost originally was written as a Facebook post in my page last October 22, Matthew's Intellectual Mosh Pit  here  . Have you ever felt before that, as you are searching into something, God is there helping you by revealing things about that thing EXPLICITLY? That's how I feel as I study Catholic Social Teaching (CST) now. It's so silly, I've been diving deep into CST for the past 3 weeks, specifically on the Church and its relationship to economic systems, and then videos like this show up. I'm convinced that God is indeed at work and is watching over me as I study the said subject matter.      First, a few days ago, I was doing something (I don't remember exactly) and then realize that an episode of a Filipino hit show, Pepito Manaloto, was playing on our TV. Specifically, it was the episode where Mimi (the character played by Nova Villa), after being elected as the home owner’s president (?), decided to let the security guards of...
Post a Comment
Read more

BREAKING: Pope Francis accepts Cardinal Wuerl's resignation as Archbishop of Washington

The episcopal throne in Washington is officially vacant. The Holy Father Francis has officially accepted the resignation of Cardinal Donald Wuerl as the Archbishop of Washington. Although he will still act in an administrative role in the Archdiocese, legally, he's no longer the head of the local church of Washington ( Here and Here .) 3 hours before I write this post, Wuerl already tweeted on the matter . -Matthew Luis Antero
Post a Comment
Read more